The Games We Play

The Games We Play

A repository of reports on the Wednesday night sessions of the club and anything else related to the club or boardgaming in general, which may be of interest to anyone who may be passing by.

Wednesday, 30 September 2009

Sessions 26 August – 23 September 2009

2 comments

26 August

With 6 people, this was the first try at Battlestar Galactica with the Pegasus expansion. The players were Ben – Caprica 6, Steve H – Ellen Tigh, Dave F – Helo, Myself – Dee, Mike – Boomer and Dave C – Tom Zarek.

Zarek was President from the beginning, but Ellen was eager for power and immediately went to Administration, despite our best attempts she was able to become president. I took this opportunity to point out that she must be a cylon, which seemed to be a reasonable assumption and also allowed me to divert attention from myself, as I was a cylon. Soon after I was able to check her loyalty card and confirm that she was indeed a cylon and in very few turns, Ellen & also Helo were able to check mine, so we cylons knew each other's identity.

The game went in a surprising way from the beginning with a series of crises that saw morale tumble rapidly and when it came to my second turn it stood at 3. This left me with an awkward decision as if it were drop to 2, Dee would have to shoot herself and be automatically revealed as a Cylon. I decided to reveal at that point so proving that my ally Ellen had been truthful in her pronouncements about me and drawing off suspicion from her.

Of course as things went, morale stopped falling at this point although things did not improve for the humans who were stopped at 6 distance due to loss of fuel, having failed to reach New Caprica.

Battlestar Galactica 170 mins.

Posn.

Player

1=

Dave D

1=

Steve H

3=

Ben C

3=

Dave C

3=

Dave F

3=

Mike


2 September

We had a good gathering this week with 7 players, first I played Ra: The Dice game with Steve Perkins and Dave F, while Steve Pagett, Mike, Gordon and Andy played Chicago Express. We then rearranged the groups, with Andy joining Steve and me for another game of Ra, followed by Keltis the card game. The other group played Rheinlander.

Andy's thoughts on the games he played

"Chicago Express

This seems to be becoming an emerging club favourite among certain members.  However the jury is still out on whether the game is good or we are just fascinated by the fact that none of us really know how to play the game properly!

After winning my first game a number of months back I've been investing in a long term strategy of exploring all the mistakes one can make in order to become a future grand master of this game.  Some would argue I'm just a bit rubbish at it, but I'm sure they're just befuddled by my maverick ways!

Four of us played; myself, Mike, Gordon, and Steve Perkins.  Only Steve hadn't played before.

It's a train game, and like most train games it involves investing in shares, building tracks and receiving dividends.  However unlike most Train games the rules are simple and plays in around an house.  Despite this it packs in a hell of a lot of game in this time.

The game is all about creating incentives - you want others to people helping you on their turn, yet you wanting to making moves that mainly benefit yourself on yours.

The trouble is it is really difficult to judge what company to invest in at what point, and it is really easy to overbid on a share and then have someone else win the same company's shares for a fraction of the price straight afterwards.  A mistake Gordon made to his immediate horror. (I made an even worse mistake in overbidding for a share that did me no good!)

I managed to get myself into a position whereby I helped Mike at least as much myself not matter what move I took.  Gordon got into a similar position with Steve, but didn't fritter his money away making futile attempts to remedy this.

The result was a joint win for Mike and Steve.

RA: The Dice Game

First game for me and Steve Perkins, second in a row for Dave Dudley.  As I've not played the original Ra before, this was completely new to me.

The game is quite a light dice rolling game, which is good fun if played on that basis.

We rolled a lot of 'suns', which caused the epoch to end quickly each time.  We therefore struggled to achieve a positive net score in each epoch - the lack of civilisations usually being the killer.

I had a narrow victory by dominating the pharoah track for the first 2 epochs, which just pipped Steve's long-term investment in Monuments.

Keltis: The Card Game

A German import I brought along.  This is the card game of the board game of the card game - Lost Cities.

It is broadly similar to Lost Cities but playable up to 4 players and with some minor additions such as Wishing Stones to consider.

As can be seen from the scoring the game cam very close.

Not an outstanding game, but a decent filler, with the bonus of it coming in a very small, easily transportable box - which could see it getting some regular play on that basis alone!"

For myself, I enjoyed a somewhat lighter session, both Ra: The Dice game and the Keltis card game played well. Ra the Dice game is Ra with dice but without the auctions and as would be expected provides a somewhat different experience, with more a push your luck element. I think both versions of the game are well worth playing. I actually found Keltis to be superior to Lost Cities, which I always thought had a problem with the opening, I don't know whether this thought is due to the fact that it is multiplayer or maybe the ability to build sequences in each direction (up or down).

Chicago Express 65 mins.

Posn.

Player

Score

1=

Steve P

72

1=

Mike

72

3

Gordon

56

4

Andy

40

Rheinlander 60 mins.

Posn.

Player

Score

1

Mike

52

2

Dave F

49

3

Gordon

30

4

Steve P

25

Ra: The Dice Game 60 mins.

Posn.

Player

Score

1

Dave D

76

2

Steve Pe

71

3

Dave F

69

Ra: The Dice Game 40 mins.

Posn.

Player

Score

1

Andy

24

2

Steve Pe

23

3

Dave D

15

Keltis: The Card Game 30 mins.

Posn.

Player

Score

1=

Andy

16

1=

Steve Pe

16

3

Dave D

15


9 September

Just Mike and me, we played 3 games of Ra: The Dice Game and 1 of Industrial Waste, I won 2 to 1 in Ra, although I have since discovered a rules error we made regarding civilisations, I don't know what difference that would have made to the scores in any of the games, although they were all close enough for a potential change of winner.

Mike won at Industrial Waste by finishing the game quickly; he was behind in innovation but had the edge on growth and money.

Ra: The Dice Game 30 mins.

Posn.

Player

Score

1

Dave D

50

2

Mike

42

Ra: The Dice Game 20 mins.

Posn.

Player

Score

1

Mike

41

2

Dave D

29

Ra: The Dice Game 20 mins.

Posn.

Player

Score

1

Dave D

51

2

Mike

47

Industrial Waste 25 mins.

Posn.

Player

Score

1

Mike

39

2

Dave D

34


16 September

Back to Pegasus, characters were Myself –Leoben, Steve H – Admiral Cain, Dave F – President Baltar, Mike – Starbuck, Andy – Helo, Donald – Apollo and later Roslin after Apollo's premature demise.

Another game where new Caprica was not reached as the humans ran out of morale at distance 6, this was despite the fact that it had briefly increased to 11 (above its starting value) early in the game. The humans were really on a hiding here, with 2 hidden cylons (Starbuck and President Baltar) from the start. I initially tried to help them from the beginning because I need them to reach distance 6, giving them the illusion of hope before bringing about their doom.

There was some discussion about this afterwards and I think we will try the optional rule of leaving out the cylon leader next time.

Battlestar Galactica 160 mins.

Posn.

Player

1=

Dave D

1=

Dave F

1=

Mike

4=

Andy

4=

Steve H

4=

Donald


23 September

4 of us played Power Grid on the German map, taking out the Red & Brown areas, leaving the northern green area isolated. I placed first in Hannover and was able to expand south making it very expensive to get in behind me.

We reached the stage where only Steve and I were in a position to start step 2 and as I was running somewhat less efficiently, I thought I would have to, but Steve beat me to it.

Coming to the end of the game in step 3, the lack of efficient fossil plants had caused both Oil and Coal to be in a position of being either run out or extremely expensive and this put Steve in a good position as he was able to run, partly on cheap nuclear power. On the final turn, I was last in the order and was the beneficiary of good fortune when the number 50 plant (2 nuke ->8) fell in my lap. If this hadn't happened, the game would still have finished and I would have been tied with Steve on 16, but he had a lot more money than me. As it was, I was able to win with 17.

Power Grid 120 mins.

Posn.

Player

Score

1

Dave D

17

2

Steve H

16

3

Mike

15

4

Donald

14



Sunday, 23 August 2009

Session Report – 19 August 2009

3 comments

7 adults this week. In the absence of Dave C, the youngsters in attendance also played board/card games, I don't have records for these but there was a strange Dominion game going on at the end of the evening.

The rest of us split 4 & 3. On one table the first game was Stone Age, which I don't like, followed by San Juan, which I do.

Stone Age 100 mins.

Posn.

Player

Score

1

Gordon

152

2

Donald

110

3

Mike

103

4

Andy

97

San Juan 40 mins.

Posn.

Player

Score

1

Gordon

35

2

Andy

32

3

Mike

26

4

Donald

21

Over on the other table Steve, Dave F & I played Arkham Horror. This being the first time the game has appeared at the club, although I did get to try it out with Dave C the Saturday previously. Since March I have been playing online games of Battlestar Galactica in the forums of Board Game Geek and many of the players in those games enjoy this one, on this basis, combined with the fact that I increasingly am seeming to prefer highly themed American games such as this plus the afore mentioned Battlestar Galactica and Fury of Dracula (compared with many of the more recent Euros (e.g. Le Havre, Comuni) which have left me cold) I decided to get the game.

The problem just diving in to a game like this is that there are really no strategy hints in the rules, so we spent much of the unfinished game wandering aimlessly closing gates as they appeared. We had no idea of things like how to get money and the importance of sealing, rather than simply closing gates.

There was also the odd rules mistake, but despite everything the game was an enjoyable experience and one that I look forward to exploring further. There is a great amount of material on the geek and I have been reading some of it, hopefully the money issues that Steve particularly had problems with should not be issues in future.

Arkham Horror 160 mins.

Posn.

Player

1=

Dave D

1=

Dave F

1=

Steve H

Wednesday, 19 August 2009

Sessions – 5,12 August 2009

1 comments

5 August

With various holidays intervening and Dave still confined with Swine Flu (although he was able to get Ben here), we had 6 this week with the attendance of Steve Perkins and Nigel. We only played 1 game, which was 6 player Race for the Galaxy and then spent some time in general gaming discussion which was an interesting change of pace.

The game was a fairly long one, as would be expected with a couple of new players; I gather it was Donald's first chance to play, despite owning the game and both its expansions. The scores were generally high and it was a very close finish with Steve's goals and developments wining out over Nigel's generally military approach. We played with both expansions although left out the takeover rules from Rebel vs. Imperium.

Race for the Galaxy 90 mins.

Posn.

Player

Score

1

Steve Pe

60

2

Nigel

59

3

Dave F

48

4

Dave D

40

5

Donald

31

6

Ben C

16


12 August

A higher attendance this week with 2 boardgames as well as role playing downstairs, which I gather Ben C was running, although Dave was back with us this week.

Upstairs on one table we had Fury of Dracula; I wanted to give the game a go as Steve had done such a wonderful job painting the figures. Steve & I have been playing a series of games and it was his turn to be the count, although in this case, there were actually 2 of us playing the hunters, it being Dave F's first game.

It took a little time for us to get on Dracula's trail, until we were able to track him down in the Prague area, there then ensued a chase that would continue for the rest of the game as he first ran south west towards Spain before heading north and then back east before setting sail into the North sea as the hunters converged from the south. He was followed by Lord Godalming who dealt him severe damage when he caught up with the count in Edinburgh. Dracula fled south, but with Mina Harker landing in London and cutting off Swansea, he was forced to head for Ireland, lacking the blood for a longer sea voyage, with Rufus Smith in play.

The game ended as Dr. Seward moved with a sense of emergency to meet the count in Galway and 2 strokes of a knife were enough to bring an end to his evil schemes.

Fury of Dracula 170 mins.

Posn.

Player

1=

Dave D

1=

Dave F

3

Steve H


On the other table was Le Havre.

Le Havre 160 mins.

Posn.

Player

Score

1

Gordon

184

2

Steve P

170

3

Donald

120

Wednesday, 5 August 2009

July 2009

2 comments
1 July
Down in the bar this week, there being the normal first Wednesday of the month committee meeting upstairs. Donald and Steve trying out Martin Wallace's Waterloo. This was not finished.

Waterloo - 150 Mins.
Posn.PlayerScore
NRSteve H
NRDonald

That left 4 of us and we opted for a number of shorter games, first up Dominion, with 2 games played and me still trying to make a Chapel strategy work with conspicuous lack of success, the first game was close though.

Dominion - 30 Mins.
Posn.PlayerScore
1Andy E27
2Dave F21+
2Mike21+
4Dave D21
Dominion - 55 Mins.
Posn.PlayerScore
1Mike41
2Andy E35
3Dave F34
4Dave D32

Next up was Fzzt! From Surprised Stare games introduced at the recent Games Expo. We quickly realised that we were making a mistake in the first try and restarted. We terminated the second game early as Mike & I had had enough of it. The game seemed to have a horrible case of runaway leader syndrome, although looking at the online rules later I think we may still have been getting something slightly wrong. I'm not sure how much difference that would have made though.

Fzzzt! - 15 Mins.
Posn.PlayerScore
1Andy E29
2Dave F28
3Mike20
4Dave D11


I left at that point and the others played what I think was a single round of Der Ausreisser (Breakaway Rider), which hasn't been played here for quite some time.

Der Ausreisser - 10 Mins.
Posn.PlayerScore
1Mike2
2Andy E-3
3Dave F-11

8 July
The evening started with a quick game of Animal Olympics, while waiting to see if anyone else would appear.

Animal Olympics - 10 Mins.
Posn.PlayerScore
1Dave F
2Mike
2Dave D
2Steve H

After that Donald arrived and Donald and he and Steve played another game of Waterloo, which again went unfinished. They both seem to like this 2 player game, but I think they have come to realise that it is probably not playable in an evening session.

Waterloo - 150 Mins.
Posn.PlayerScore
NRSteve H
NRDonald

The rest of us played Industrial Waste, which was a very close game, Mike taking by virtue of getting to the end of the growth track and having a bit more money than me. It was Dave's first game and he was a little held back at the beginning due to a misunderstanding of the fact that accidents happen immediately the card is drawn rather than at the end of the turn, so he did not have a chance to get his waste back into the green.

Industrial Waste - 60 Mins.
Posn.PlayerScore
1Mike60
2Dave D55
3Dave F28

Finally we introduced Dave to San Juan, which I gather he was so impressed with he went and got it and has also been playing a PC version a lot. Mike and I were on pretty much the same sort of strategy with City Hall, Palace and Chapel; I won, despite Mike being the one to finish the game by virtue of having more monuments.

San Juan - 40 Mins.
Posn.PlayerScore
1Dave D41
2Mike40
3Dave F26

15 July
First up was 7 player Tsuro

Tsuro - 10 Mins.
Posn.PlayerScore
1Ben C
1Gordon
3Dave D
4Daniel
4Mike
6Donald
7Steve H

Then we split 4 & 3, with 4 of us going with Race for the Galaxy, first time with Rebel vs. Imperium, although we left out the takeovers.

Race for the Galaxy - 70 Mins.
Posn.PlayerScore
1Dave D56
2Steve H36
3Daniel27
4Ben C25

Also we played Dominion, which I won for a change using Throne Room/Council Room.

Dominion - 35 Mins.
Posn.PlayerScore
1Dave D44
2Ben C24
2Daniel24
4Steve H20

Over on the other table, they played Chicago Express

Chicago Express - 60 Mins.
Posn.PlayerScore
1Donald142
2Gordon123
3Mike119

And also Dominion
Posn.PlayerScore
1Mike39
2Gordon31
3Donald15

22 July
We had 3 tables this week, with Dave taking on the youngsters at Runebound; I don't have results for this one.
4 of us played Metropolys; this has been played once before with 3 of the same players. I ended up second again.

Metropolys - 75 Mins.
Posn.PlayerScore
1Andy E37
2Dave D35
3Dave F29
4Mike26

Then it was 2 games of Dominion, the first being very close (3 way tie) and the second, after Andy left, less so, basically being decided on curses. Mike did very well chapelling away most of his while dumping quite a few on Dave and me. I made the mistake of staying out of the Witch game and again proved totally incapable of getting Chapel and curses together in the same hand.

Dominion - 45 Mins.
Posn.PlayerScore
1Dave F31
1Dave D31
1Mike31
4Andy E25
Dominion - 30 Mins.
Posn.PlayerScore
1Mike48
2Dave F36
3Dave D23

Over on the other table the game was Le Havre and it went on for the entire evening, still going after I left (which was fairly late). Gordon sent the following in an email.
The result for our game of Le Havre was Donald 118, Steve P 110 and me 83. We had to rush the last couple of turns which resulted in me collecting 3 loans and minus 21 points on the last round which I could probably have avoided. I knew from the reports I had read that it would be the kind of game I would enjoy and it lived up to the billing. It is however a big undertaking and I quiet understand Mike's view that we have enough barely understood games without taking this on. It is going to take at least 3 games to feel comfortable with the way the game plays out. I only have room for 1 or 2 games of this weight a year because of the need for multiple plays. I hope to drag some others into the learning experience. I suspect Steve Hilton will like it and young Andy and new Dave. I would not want to play a game with more than 3. We played Donald's copy but I also have the game.

For myself, I played the game at Midcon and didn't enjoy the experience, see here.

29 July
5 this week, plus Munchkin for the youngsters (I don't have any info on that)
To a start with Andy introduced Tulipmania, which has been somewhat delayed, I believe it was supposed to be out at Essen last year. It is an interesting game, but I think will require further play to determine whether there is anything there or whether it is just a case of speculating and hoping for the best. In this game, I thought I was right out of it when I wasn't involved when the first bubble burst and speculated that there might be a bit of Acquire there, where if you miss out on the first merger and can't make another one fairly quickly, you can really lose out. As it turned out I finished third, when I was expecting to be last, being particularly surprised to beat Steve who did very well out of that first burst.

Tulipmania 1637 - 60 Mins.
Posn.PlayerScore
1Dave F22175
2Andy E21675
3Dave D16400
4Steve H15750
5Mike9050

After that we had a bit of a quandary due to a lack of 5 player games that would play in half a session. Many thanks to Mike for agreeing to play RftG, when I know he is not a fan of the game. Steve won this one with his military juggernaut and Improved Logistics.

Race for the Galaxy - 75 Mins.
Posn.PlayerScore
1Steve H42
2Mike25+
3Andy E25
4Dave D20
5Dave F14

Wednesday, 8 July 2009

Catch Up 10,17,24 June

1 comments

Just a few notes by way of catching up.

Games Expo

I was at Games Expo on the Saturday and Sunday, but didn't actually play many games. Saturday morning was spent was spent demoing Great Fire, which seemed to go down well. Feedback was positive and Richard Denning is going to look for a publisher on that basis. There have been another couple of changes in the game since then and I hope to get the game on the table again to try them out.

Saturday afternoon was spent wandering including a game of Battle Line (old Knizia title) with Mike, it's OK for a 2 player game, but not one I'd want to play regularly.

Sunday morning was more wandering before going back and actually playing Great Fire in the afternoon. Dave & Ben were also around both days playing parts in the Living Dungeon.

10 June

We had to wait for the room upstairs to become free, so spent some time in the bar playing some short games. 6 of us played a couple of games of Tsuro.

Posn.
Player
1
Mike
2
Ben C
3=
Dave F
3=
Dave D
3=
Steve H
6
Steve Pe
Posn.
Player
1
Steve H
2
Dave F
3=
Mike
3=
Ben C
5
Steve Pe
6
Dave D
While Dave C and another 3 tried Days of Steam, which he had picked up at the expo. The game was not completed before we moved upstairs. I had a chance to try this with Dave (2 player) on the following Saturday and it seemed OK, but probably needs more players. It seems fairly light and could make a reasonable filler.

Posn.
Player
1=
Dave C
1=
Paul
1=
Donald
1=
Nigel
We moved upstairs and split into 2 5 player groups. On one table was Pillars of the Earth, I think this was Dave's first try at the game, Ben had played once before but not with the expansion. The 2 Steves finished comfortably ahead, with the rest of us trailing.

Posn.
Player
Score
1
Steve H
55
2
Steve Pe
52
3
Dave D
43
4
Dave F
41
5
Ben C
35
On the other table was Automobile, the new Martin Wallace and another one that Dave had picked up at Expo, I had thought about getting this myself, but knowing that Dave & Andy had both bought copies decided against. The game seemed to go down well and I enjoyed my try the following week.

Posn.
Player
Score
1
Mike
3990
2
Paul
3680
3
Nigel
2870
4
Dave C
2810
5
Donald
2790
17 June

7 this week and a 4/3 split.

I had my first try at Automobile, which ended with a second win for Mike, I think this a game that's going to take a few trys to get the strategy. I gather though that after 2 wins Mike came a bit of a cropper at the Rosliston weekend, speaking of which I'd be interested in seeing some sort of info about the games played there.

Posn.
Player
Score
1
Mike
4680
2
Dave D
4150
3
Donald
4040
4
Dave C
3050
We finished off with Tsuro

Posn.
Player
1
Mike
2
Dave C
3
Dave D
4
Donald
On the other table the first game was Stone Age, a game which I didn't take to when I tried it

Posn.
Player
Score
1
Steve H
165
2
Gordon
159
3
Dave F
155
Followed by an old favourite, Ra, I see that Gordon didn't win for once.

Posn.
Player
Score
1
Steve H
56
2
Gordon
52
3
Dave F
40
24 June

With 8 players, we started with Tsuro, while waiting to see if Dave & Ben would appear.

Posn.
Player
1
Donald
2
Steve P
3
Gordon
4
Mike
5=
Dave D
5=
Daniel
7=
Steve H
7=
Dave F
After that it was another 4/4 split, no one else having arrived. 4 of us played Power Grid. Dave was new to the game and Daniel, I gather, has not that much experience. We used the China board, which I think could be my favourite. It has a slow build up due to the ordered appearance of the power plants, but this seems to lead to a great climax.

This was the closest game I have known with all 4 players tied and separated by money. There were only a few elektros between Dave & myself at the end and he would have won, if he hadn't spent 2 much on buying extra raw materials he didn't need, I think it was a case of inexperience showing. Steve was looking good for a lot of the game, having been left quite isolated in the south, but lost out at the end, when he went last to build and there were only 2 cities available in the far north, the connection costs were enough to drop him down to last.

Posn.
Player
Score
1
Dave D
17+++
2
Dave F
17++
3
Daniel
17+
4
Steve H
17
On the other table was In the Year of the Dragon

Posn.
Player
Score
1
Gordon
98
2
Donald
89
3
Steve P
88
4
Mike
68
And Dominion, I don't have the scores or positions for this game, although I am told that Gordon won.

Posn.
Player
1
Gordon
2=
Donald
2=
Steve P
2=
Mike