The Games We Play
The Games We Play
A repository of reports on the Wednesday night sessions of the club and anything else related to the club or boardgaming in general, which may be of interest to anyone who may be passing by.
Pages
Thursday, 9 August 2007
Corporation - the first mission
I've posted the write-up of the first mission on my blog
Labels:
Non-Boardgames
Sunday, 5 August 2007
Hamstercon - 4th August 2007
Having had to work in the morning, me and Ben set off for Luke’s games day in the afternoon, arriving about 2.45pm. The place was easy to find; the upstairs room was a decent size with plenty of tables. A games library had been provided so there was no shortage of stuff to try.
When we arrived, Dave D was already there, deep in a game of Power Grid. Having been relieved of our entrance fee, we were introduced to a guy named Chris and immediately set to playing Age of Empires III. This is currently Ben’s fave as he trashed me at it on Thursday night. The game went well and lasted about 2 hours; Ben pulled off another decisive victory with an inspired use of the University on the final turn. Chris was second, I trailed in third.
Steve Pagetis had arrived, I stopped for a brief word and to watch the game of Tempus (must play this again).
Ben wanted to play HeroScape so we set up a basic two-player game. It drew a few admiring comments from onlookers; the game is fun to play and the modular terrain and pre-painted miniatures are excellent. The dragon figure, in full colour, is nearly 6” long and 6” high to wingtip. An awesome model. Ben won 13:4 in about an hour.
A young lady named Gemma was interested in playing Tikal, so whilst our Heroscape game finished Dave D introduced them to Canal Mania. A chap named Jonny came over and introduced himself and got chatting to Ben; we then tried a new game called Hey, That’s my Fish! In this, you play a colony of penguins zooming around an ice floe, catching fish. As the game progresses the ice floe fragments, eventually you can’t move and you’re out. Once everyone is out then you score your catch. Jonny won the first game; me and Ben tied in second. The game was such fun we played again, this game was more tactical; Jonny won again, Ben was second and I came third.
We then broke for something to eat; as Dave D, Gemma and that group were still playing Canal Mania. When we returned, they had vanished, so we ate tea and chatted in general to Luke, Anna and several other people whose name I never found out.
Dave D then wandered back so I suggested another game of Age of Empires III. We gained a fourth player named Connor and settled down. This game took longer, nearly three hours and ended in a win for DD. I came second, Ben was third with Connor fourth. As Dave himself pointed out, he scored a lot in the final round on colonies as was surprised no-one tried to stop him. I was the only one with a soldier, taking over Brazil; but Connor just kept putting in more men so the battles dragged on a bit. I got it in the end however. It was now 11pm so we returned home.
Overall, it was a great day. Ben really enjoyed it; and can’t wait for the next games con. I think he’ll be coming to MidCon this year. We never got to play Tikal – maybe next time. Thanks to Luke and the other organisers for putting it on; you’ve got to do it again. And for everyone who couldn’t make it: - try and get to the next one.
When we arrived, Dave D was already there, deep in a game of Power Grid. Having been relieved of our entrance fee, we were introduced to a guy named Chris and immediately set to playing Age of Empires III. This is currently Ben’s fave as he trashed me at it on Thursday night. The game went well and lasted about 2 hours; Ben pulled off another decisive victory with an inspired use of the University on the final turn. Chris was second, I trailed in third.
Steve Pagetis had arrived, I stopped for a brief word and to watch the game of Tempus (must play this again).
Ben wanted to play HeroScape so we set up a basic two-player game. It drew a few admiring comments from onlookers; the game is fun to play and the modular terrain and pre-painted miniatures are excellent. The dragon figure, in full colour, is nearly 6” long and 6” high to wingtip. An awesome model. Ben won 13:4 in about an hour.
A young lady named Gemma was interested in playing Tikal, so whilst our Heroscape game finished Dave D introduced them to Canal Mania. A chap named Jonny came over and introduced himself and got chatting to Ben; we then tried a new game called Hey, That’s my Fish! In this, you play a colony of penguins zooming around an ice floe, catching fish. As the game progresses the ice floe fragments, eventually you can’t move and you’re out. Once everyone is out then you score your catch. Jonny won the first game; me and Ben tied in second. The game was such fun we played again, this game was more tactical; Jonny won again, Ben was second and I came third.
We then broke for something to eat; as Dave D, Gemma and that group were still playing Canal Mania. When we returned, they had vanished, so we ate tea and chatted in general to Luke, Anna and several other people whose name I never found out.
Dave D then wandered back so I suggested another game of Age of Empires III. We gained a fourth player named Connor and settled down. This game took longer, nearly three hours and ended in a win for DD. I came second, Ben was third with Connor fourth. As Dave himself pointed out, he scored a lot in the final round on colonies as was surprised no-one tried to stop him. I was the only one with a soldier, taking over Brazil; but Connor just kept putting in more men so the battles dragged on a bit. I got it in the end however. It was now 11pm so we returned home.
Overall, it was a great day. Ben really enjoyed it; and can’t wait for the next games con. I think he’ll be coming to MidCon this year. We never got to play Tikal – maybe next time. Thanks to Luke and the other organisers for putting it on; you’ve got to do it again. And for everyone who couldn’t make it: - try and get to the next one.
Labels:
Conventions
Friday, 3 August 2007
Session Summary - 1 August 2007
With the vagaries of holidays and such like, it was just me and Steve this week, and that of course meant:
I am Count Dracula, eight years ago, I set out to bring the rule of the undead to this world, but was defeated by a group of mortals, or so they thought. How could they truly hope to stop one such as I? I who commanded armies hundreds of years before they born, for now I have returned and taken my place astride the world, despite the pathetic efforts of my past antagonists, my undead minions are in every city to do my bidding.
| Fury of Dracula 180 mins | |
| Player | Posn. |
| Dave D (Dracula) | Won |
| Steve H (Hunters) | |
I am Count Dracula, eight years ago, I set out to bring the rule of the undead to this world, but was defeated by a group of mortals, or so they thought. How could they truly hope to stop one such as I? I who commanded armies hundreds of years before they born, for now I have returned and taken my place astride the world, despite the pathetic efforts of my past antagonists, my undead minions are in every city to do my bidding.
Day 1
My campaign began in the Black Sea port of Constanta, within easy reach of my great ancestral castle and close to my old foe, Abraham Van Helsing, who learning of my return had travelled to Bucharest, but all was not yet ready, so as dawn broke on that first day, I remained in Constanta and called my dark servants to me, knowing that even should Van Helsing find me, he had had no time to prepare for a battle, even in daylight.
By some inspiration, or pure chance, Van Helsing came to Constanta , but the ensuing battle was inconclusive and following this I departed to Galatz , while he searched Varna to no avail. As the day drew to a close, I sheltered in Castle Dracula, recovering from my exertions, before taking the shape of a great wolf and racing to Belgrade before heading south toward Greece .
Day 2
I arrived in Athens as dawn broke on the second day, creating a new undead, which perhaps would advance me toward my goal. The hunters had deduced my path, but I would set sail before they reached me and I hoped that they, seeing I had eluded them, would turn back before entering the city. I had also by this time been able to gather many resources with the aid of the fearful Immanuel Hildesheim. I was to be surprised, however when Doctor Seward, riding as if the devil was behind him entered the city before I was able to leave, he was however in no shape following his desperate ride to cause much trouble, even in daylight, and I was able to slip away into the Ionian Sea, followed by Seward and, shortly after, by Van Helsing. My new child had been easily dispatched, but I could make more.
I did not wish to linger long at sea, due to the insidious activities of Rufus Smith, who would cause me much pain, were I to remain afloat too long, so I proceeded into the Adriatic and landed at Bari , hoping to conceal a vampire at the foot of Italy . Seward sailed on into the Tyrrhenian and I believe both my pursuers would have missed me, were it not for the accursed accountants who somehow revealed my sea route, allowing the hunters to locate me, knowing that Lord Godalming had been in Venice at the time I landed. Seward landed at Naples , travelling on to Rome to join Godalming, Van Helsing also going to Naples via the Tyrrhenian. They expected to catch me in one of these two locations at Dusk, but, with time running short, it was now twilight and I remained in Bari marshalling a great swarm of bats to protect my vampire.
At midnight I again took wolf form and passed through Rome to Florence , avoiding Seward and Godalming, and then onto Venice with unearthly speed, putting distance between us. Van Helsing went to Bari to investigate the city but was driven back to Naples by the bats.
Day 3
At dawn, I reached Nuremburg and gathered more bats, having passed through Munich in the small hours and felt the touch of a stake in my heart as Van Helsing, returning in the nick of time destroyed my child in Bari . Still I pressed on and sired another vampire in Leipzig before travelling to Frankfurt , then Cologne , laying traps for my pursuers as I went. Seward and Godalming were approaching from the south by different routes, though Seward was driven back by the bats in Nuremburg. Van Helsing was returning up Italy , while Mina Harker, who would be so important in my victory, but had so far, played little part in the story approached from the west, having suffered many delays due to defective travelling papers (not all of them entirely accidental).
I reached Amsterdam at midnight using my powers to cloak the city in a great storm intending to set sail and so lose the hunters in this way. I found, however, another way to evade the pursuit, as friendly agents were able to spirit me away to Galatz , before my ship departed. Almost at the same time, Mina was entering Leipzig , where she found my vampire. She thought she was forewarned of anything she might encounter, but my great power deceived her and the vampire was ready. So Mina was seduced and fell victim again to the bite of the undead, bringing oblivion (if it were not for the soon to be damned sisters of St. Joseph and St. Mary) and a massive boost to my quest for domination.
The small hours brought things full circle as I returned to Constanta to bring another vampire into existence.
Day 4
At dawn I remained in Constanta gathering bats, but the hunters had not been idle, their scouts having revealed my visit to Amsterdam , while newspapers pointed them in the direction of Galatz . Seward and Godalming immediately headed east, while Van Helsing rushed to Galatz with great resolve. Mina was already at hand, having recovered from her encounter and left the convent for Szeged .
I knew that by surviving the day, victory would be mine, but things would be resolved sooner than that. I moved to Bucharest and then to Sofia (the consecrated Belgrade being closed to me) at dusk, gathering a pack of wolves to my side in time for the arrival of Mina. Ah, the children of the night, what music they made as they tore at her flesh in that last hour before sunset. Having escaped the wolves, she had the audacity to attack me. I tried to send her horse wild, but this failed due to some miraculous luck, which no hunter had previously possessed. Enraged by this I dashed the stake she carried from her hands and the battle began. Although she did me some minor harm with sacred bullets, when these were finished the battle proved inconclusive in the last minutes of daylight.
It was to be a short reprieve for Mina as, when night fell, I went out into the streets of Sofia and fed to restore the blood I had just lost. Then I sought her out and this time without the sun’s interference, the battle was short. I immediately caught her in my gaze and bit her as she stood mesmerised. I was victorious!
Wonderful game, it's Steve's turn to be Dracula next time. Until next week.
Labels:
Wednesday Sessions
Tuesday, 31 July 2007
Session Summary - 25 July 2007
There was a good attendance this week, with Simon and Gordon in attendance and various younger members due to Summer Holidays. Dave, ran a Talislanta game downstairs for the children downstairs and his report is online here. Dave Maybe you could ley me have details of the players?. Meanwhile that left 6 of us and a game of:
| Power Grid 120 mins | ||
| Player | Posn. | Points |
| Dave D | 1 | 15++ |
| Gordon | 2 | 15+ |
| Mike | 3 | 15 |
| Simon | 4 | 14++ |
| Steve H | 5 | 14+ |
| Richard B | 6 | 14 |
At the beginning, no body paid much if anything over the face value for their plants and this was the general pattern throughout the game. I picked up the #13 wind plant, which put me in the position to build last in the first turn, giving me a chance to look at where everyone else set up. I went with Brussel, just by Steve & Gordon, but with expansion room to the west and south. Mike was next to the north east, while Richard sat in the North of the board near the cheapest connections and Simon, who I think was the only one with a 2 capacity plant, staked out a couple of cities in the east. In the following couple of turns, every one got intermingled, the low connection costs allowing everyone to jump over each other.
From turn 2 the high value plants started coming out, with some over 30 making it into the current market, this caused a bit of thinking (at least it did me) as to whether it was worth buying at this stage as the cost of the plant would severely curtail building in the short term. I eventually bought the #21 hybrid (2 fuel - 4 cities), Richard picked the #34 nuclear (5 cities) and Steve took (I think) the #32 (3 oil - 6 cities).
People expanded over a couple of turns to 5 cities and during this time, I picked up the #30 plant (3 trash - 6 cities) for 42, which I think was the highest premium paid in the game and even so I think it was very good deal. The game did not stall at 5 cities however as Simon immediately took the game into step 2. I did not need to use the #30 immediately and by the time I did, the trash price had reached rock bottom, due to the high refresh rate in a 6 player game in step 2.
The plant market now stalled somewhat as lower plants came out and I competed a little with Steve for #24 (2 trash - 4 cities), before letting him have it, not being too concerned about losing the trash monopoly and hoping something better would replace it. Unfortunately the new plant was #23 (1 nuclear - 3 cities) much to my (and Gordon's disappointment) and everyone passed for the rest of the round.
I was now a bit apprehensive because I was behind on capacity to Steve and Richard, who could power 14, but I was hopeful that Step 3 would turn up when we got to bureaucracy. It didn't and the plants on offer next turn weren't good, but fortunately no one could finish that round and when Step 3 did arrive for the following turn, I was able to pick up #25 (2 coal - 5 cities) giving me 15 capacity, Gordon also went to 15 capacity and Mike was on 16, while the others were on 14. I think Gordon ended the game and the game was decide as it frequently is on the money tie break. I think Mike said he was 8 away from building a 16th. city.
There had been some discussion during the game about the desirability of limiting the number of plants you buy during the game to 5. Thinking afterward, I know that both I & Gordon had only bought 4 during this one, so maybe for 6 players, with a smaller (14) end condition this is the way to go.
Until next week (well that's tomorrow now).
Labels:
Wednesday Sessions
Sunday, 22 July 2007
Session Summary - 18 July 2007
3 Players and a game new to Wednesday evening.
Caylus Magna Carta 130 mins
Player Posn. Points
Steve H 1 61
Matt 2 60
Dave D 3 50
According to my records, I have played Caylus 4 times, actually winning on a couple of occasions, this however has been enough to decide that the game isn't really for me, seeming as it does to be far too dry with too much going on and a play time such that the game has outlived it's welcome, well before the end. Some (though not all) of these problems I would also attribute to Puerto Rico.
Now we have Caylus Magna Carta, the card version of Caylus and I have been interested to see whether I would find the same with this as I have found with San Juan, the card version of Puerto Rico and a game I like so much that I note it is the game for which I have most recorded plays, 31 and I know there are others that haven't been recorded.
Anyway enough of all that, what was the game like. First of all, as I have heard said, this is a lot closer to Caylus than San Juan is to Puerto Rico. It retains much of the board game, with the castle and the road and the provost moving to specify which buildings can be activated. The difference is that the road is now built (except for a few starting buildings) with cards from players hands. Unlike San Juan, when cards are drawn from a central stock, each player has a small(I seem to remember 10 cards, but may be wrong) individual deck, identical to all the other players, with various buildings on one side, each being backed by a residence into which each can be converted later on. There are also seven prestige buildings in a general supply that can be built from a residence. Again unlike San Juan, the cards are not multi purpose and only represent buildings (rather than money and production), building costs are payed using resources.
So what's the play like?
Each player gets a hand of 3 cards at the start, which he can choose to discard and draw 3 new if they are not to his liking. If he doesn't like the new 3 then it's tough.
At the start of a round, each player gets money equal to 2 + the number of residences he has.
Then each player, in turn, may pay 1 to take one of the following actions:
1.Place a worker on an available building.
2.Draw a card.
3.Exchange all cards in hand for a like number from supply.
Alternatively they may build a building from hand by paying the required resources or pass after which they may take no further actions that turn, the first one to pass receives 1 money.
After all have passed, bribery takes place as in Caylus, with each player in pass order able to spend up to 3 to move the provost, following which buildings are activated (if workers are on them) in order from the top of the road to the position of the provost. Each building has 2 effects, first giving something to the player whose worker is on them and then something (usually less) to the player owning the building, which can act as a disincentive to moving the provost back, if by so doing, you lose something yourself (in addition to the bribe cost).
After this parts of the castle are built (again in pass order, this being unlike Caylus), with early parts earning 4 VP each, while later parts are worth 3 and then 2. Whoever puts in the most or is first in the case of a tie, gets one gold.
Finally the first player moves to the next in clockwise order (a much more natural thing to do than the awkwardness in Caylus) and play continues with the next turn.
This goes on until all parts of the castle are built at which time the game is over and VPs are scored for Castle sections built, buildings built that are still on the road and 1 for each gold, each 3 of the other resources and (I think) each 3 money.
In this game, Steve earned a lot of points from castle building, plus building the major prestige building, Matt ignored the castle for a lot of the time and earned a lot from building a lot of buildings. I think I made a mistake at the start by not changing my starting hand which included 2 out of 3 buildings needing stone (which you don't start with) and then I was reluctant to build the remaining one because Steve built an identical one immediately before me, thinking it was may be not good to duplicate buildings, my thinking being that people were more likely to use his because it wasn't so far down the road. In retrospect, I now don't see the problem as the supplies of goods to the owner are limited for the cheaper buildings and the provost soon moved far enough, so as not to make much difference. Equally, after the 4 point castle sections ran out, I was reluctant to go for them when I didn't have a chace to get the gold, perhaps in this way giving Steve more points from this method than he should have had. I think maybe I was in a Caylus mindset here, but as far as I can see in retrospect the points would have been useful and the bonus of a gold in this game is nowhere near as significant as a favour in Caylus. It is worth noting here that the situation here with Steve so often building before me, indicates that there is far more of an incentive to be first to pass than in Caylus.
Inevitably, there is an element of luck with the card draw in this game, perhaps particularly in getting your Lawyer built, because if you can get it down early before people start building residences, you stand to make a lot of money. Matt did well with this and Steve to a lesser extent, whereas I didn't get mine until the end of the game and only made the VP from it. Then again there are ways of cycling your deck in this game, which I consistently forgot about, so this factor should be somewhat controllable with more competent play. I made the bulk of my points from some early castle building and a couple of big prestige buildings.
So what do I think?
I'd definitely take this over Caylus, the elimination of favours takes out most of the fiddly complication which most disappoints me about that game. A random factor is present, but because of the small deck size and ways to cycle, this should be somewhat mitigated. My problem with this play of the game is with the game length. In this game, possibly because of my reluctance to join Steve in building the castle, when I couldn't get gold and because of Matt's lack of interest in same, there was a long period when only one section was built every turn, so delaying the finish. I'm hoping (and expecting) therefore that this play was an aberration (like the 2 hour Industrial Waste game). Comments on the geek suggest that 15-20 minutes per player, shouldn't be too far out and if that is the case I could see this getting a bit of play (including by me). Steve has suggested he think 90 minutes would be normal, but I have to say that sounds a bit too long. I can see this as one of 2 approximately equal length games for a session, but am not so sure about the idea of playing it with only time for a filler at the end.
I've started giving each game I play a rating on the geek and have currently awarded this 6.5, which is my standard when I'm fence sitting, this will rise if the length question resolves OK or otherwise probably drop to 6.
Until next Wednesday
Caylus Magna Carta 130 mins
Player Posn. Points
Steve H 1 61
Matt 2 60
Dave D 3 50
According to my records, I have played Caylus 4 times, actually winning on a couple of occasions, this however has been enough to decide that the game isn't really for me, seeming as it does to be far too dry with too much going on and a play time such that the game has outlived it's welcome, well before the end. Some (though not all) of these problems I would also attribute to Puerto Rico.
Now we have Caylus Magna Carta, the card version of Caylus and I have been interested to see whether I would find the same with this as I have found with San Juan, the card version of Puerto Rico and a game I like so much that I note it is the game for which I have most recorded plays, 31 and I know there are others that haven't been recorded.
Anyway enough of all that, what was the game like. First of all, as I have heard said, this is a lot closer to Caylus than San Juan is to Puerto Rico. It retains much of the board game, with the castle and the road and the provost moving to specify which buildings can be activated. The difference is that the road is now built (except for a few starting buildings) with cards from players hands. Unlike San Juan, when cards are drawn from a central stock, each player has a small(I seem to remember 10 cards, but may be wrong) individual deck, identical to all the other players, with various buildings on one side, each being backed by a residence into which each can be converted later on. There are also seven prestige buildings in a general supply that can be built from a residence. Again unlike San Juan, the cards are not multi purpose and only represent buildings (rather than money and production), building costs are payed using resources.
So what's the play like?
Each player gets a hand of 3 cards at the start, which he can choose to discard and draw 3 new if they are not to his liking. If he doesn't like the new 3 then it's tough.
At the start of a round, each player gets money equal to 2 + the number of residences he has.
Then each player, in turn, may pay 1 to take one of the following actions:
1.Place a worker on an available building.
2.Draw a card.
3.Exchange all cards in hand for a like number from supply.
Alternatively they may build a building from hand by paying the required resources or pass after which they may take no further actions that turn, the first one to pass receives 1 money.
After all have passed, bribery takes place as in Caylus, with each player in pass order able to spend up to 3 to move the provost, following which buildings are activated (if workers are on them) in order from the top of the road to the position of the provost. Each building has 2 effects, first giving something to the player whose worker is on them and then something (usually less) to the player owning the building, which can act as a disincentive to moving the provost back, if by so doing, you lose something yourself (in addition to the bribe cost).
After this parts of the castle are built (again in pass order, this being unlike Caylus), with early parts earning 4 VP each, while later parts are worth 3 and then 2. Whoever puts in the most or is first in the case of a tie, gets one gold.
Finally the first player moves to the next in clockwise order (a much more natural thing to do than the awkwardness in Caylus) and play continues with the next turn.
This goes on until all parts of the castle are built at which time the game is over and VPs are scored for Castle sections built, buildings built that are still on the road and 1 for each gold, each 3 of the other resources and (I think) each 3 money.
In this game, Steve earned a lot of points from castle building, plus building the major prestige building, Matt ignored the castle for a lot of the time and earned a lot from building a lot of buildings. I think I made a mistake at the start by not changing my starting hand which included 2 out of 3 buildings needing stone (which you don't start with) and then I was reluctant to build the remaining one because Steve built an identical one immediately before me, thinking it was may be not good to duplicate buildings, my thinking being that people were more likely to use his because it wasn't so far down the road. In retrospect, I now don't see the problem as the supplies of goods to the owner are limited for the cheaper buildings and the provost soon moved far enough, so as not to make much difference. Equally, after the 4 point castle sections ran out, I was reluctant to go for them when I didn't have a chace to get the gold, perhaps in this way giving Steve more points from this method than he should have had. I think maybe I was in a Caylus mindset here, but as far as I can see in retrospect the points would have been useful and the bonus of a gold in this game is nowhere near as significant as a favour in Caylus. It is worth noting here that the situation here with Steve so often building before me, indicates that there is far more of an incentive to be first to pass than in Caylus.
Inevitably, there is an element of luck with the card draw in this game, perhaps particularly in getting your Lawyer built, because if you can get it down early before people start building residences, you stand to make a lot of money. Matt did well with this and Steve to a lesser extent, whereas I didn't get mine until the end of the game and only made the VP from it. Then again there are ways of cycling your deck in this game, which I consistently forgot about, so this factor should be somewhat controllable with more competent play. I made the bulk of my points from some early castle building and a couple of big prestige buildings.
So what do I think?
I'd definitely take this over Caylus, the elimination of favours takes out most of the fiddly complication which most disappoints me about that game. A random factor is present, but because of the small deck size and ways to cycle, this should be somewhat mitigated. My problem with this play of the game is with the game length. In this game, possibly because of my reluctance to join Steve in building the castle, when I couldn't get gold and because of Matt's lack of interest in same, there was a long period when only one section was built every turn, so delaying the finish. I'm hoping (and expecting) therefore that this play was an aberration (like the 2 hour Industrial Waste game). Comments on the geek suggest that 15-20 minutes per player, shouldn't be too far out and if that is the case I could see this getting a bit of play (including by me). Steve has suggested he think 90 minutes would be normal, but I have to say that sounds a bit too long. I can see this as one of 2 approximately equal length games for a session, but am not so sure about the idea of playing it with only time for a filler at the end.
I've started giving each game I play a rating on the geek and have currently awarded this 6.5, which is my standard when I'm fence sitting, this will rise if the length question resolves OK or otherwise probably drop to 6.
Until next Wednesday
Labels:
Wednesday Sessions
Friday, 13 July 2007
Session Summary - 11 July 2007
After the long & delayed report from last week, this promises to be somewhat shorter, despite having 2 games to talk about, as I have to be honest and confess I can't think of much to say.
Steve mentioned this one in his Rosliston report and I'm inclined to agree with what he says. There is a lot to think about here with multiple ways to score Victory points. The basic mechanism of the game is a series of auctions (of the round the table type) to acquire buildings of 5 different colours which are used to build cities (granting Victory points) and when laid in front of a player, allowing the majority and second place holders in a particular colour to gain roles in the 5 colours, which give an immediate special privilege and also the opportunity to gain VPs when other players build cities using buildings of that colour. There are also pieces to be placed on a board (due to building cities and one of the colour roles) which give VPs using an area majority system at game end.
In this game Steve seemed to be running away early on but was hauled in at the end when all the sundry end game VPs were given out. I was in a position at the end of the game of having quite a lot more money than the rest, probably an indication that I had been a bit too thrifty earlier on, but it did get me a bonus 2 VP at the end, and I was also able to get a role for another couple. At this point I must say that I have discovered an error in regards to money, apparently (according to a post on the geek by the designer) it is not open. I don't know what it says in the rules, but it seems a bit crazy when the currency is in the form of cardboard coins of different colours and sizes and no player screens are provided that this should be the case.
Verdict - interesting game, must play again, jury still out regards longevity.
This is a game I've only played sporadically (make that 3 times including this one) and always find myself in the position of having to remember what I'm doing at the beginning. The theme of the evening was obviously auctions as this is just really one auction after another, this time of the once round type, with the player initiating the auction having the last bid. The clever part is deciding what to bid on as there are 2 goals, getting the highest value and accumulating majorities in the different commodities on offer that are often contradictory. This game seemed to go on a bit long compared with memories of the previous 2 games, but maybe that was due to more players than previously and possibly faulty memory.
There was some discussion comparing this and Ra and opinion is split. I can see that this game is popular (it must be or it wouldn't keep getting reprinted), but to me Ra is considerably better.
Verdict - OK, I can't see that I'd ever refuse a game if it was all that was on offer, but there are a lot that I'd play in preference.
Anyway that was quite enough auction action for one session. I think I need to steer clear of auctions for a bit, unless they're in a Power Grid context (or may be Ra).
Until next week
| Il Principe 90 mins | ||
| Player | Posn. | Points |
| Richard B | 1 | 53+ |
| Matt | 2 | 53 |
| Steve H | 3 | 49 |
| Dave D | 4 | 45 |
| Mike | 5 | 41 |
Steve mentioned this one in his Rosliston report and I'm inclined to agree with what he says. There is a lot to think about here with multiple ways to score Victory points. The basic mechanism of the game is a series of auctions (of the round the table type) to acquire buildings of 5 different colours which are used to build cities (granting Victory points) and when laid in front of a player, allowing the majority and second place holders in a particular colour to gain roles in the 5 colours, which give an immediate special privilege and also the opportunity to gain VPs when other players build cities using buildings of that colour. There are also pieces to be placed on a board (due to building cities and one of the colour roles) which give VPs using an area majority system at game end.
In this game Steve seemed to be running away early on but was hauled in at the end when all the sundry end game VPs were given out. I was in a position at the end of the game of having quite a lot more money than the rest, probably an indication that I had been a bit too thrifty earlier on, but it did get me a bonus 2 VP at the end, and I was also able to get a role for another couple. At this point I must say that I have discovered an error in regards to money, apparently (according to a post on the geek by the designer) it is not open. I don't know what it says in the rules, but it seems a bit crazy when the currency is in the form of cardboard coins of different colours and sizes and no player screens are provided that this should be the case.
Verdict - interesting game, must play again, jury still out regards longevity.
| Medici 75 mins | ||
| Player | Posn. | Points |
| Matt | 1 | 120 |
| Richard B | 2 | 95 |
| Steve H | 3 | 92 |
| Dave D | 4 | 84 |
| Mike | 5 | 73 |
This is a game I've only played sporadically (make that 3 times including this one) and always find myself in the position of having to remember what I'm doing at the beginning. The theme of the evening was obviously auctions as this is just really one auction after another, this time of the once round type, with the player initiating the auction having the last bid. The clever part is deciding what to bid on as there are 2 goals, getting the highest value and accumulating majorities in the different commodities on offer that are often contradictory. This game seemed to go on a bit long compared with memories of the previous 2 games, but maybe that was due to more players than previously and possibly faulty memory.
There was some discussion comparing this and Ra and opinion is split. I can see that this game is popular (it must be or it wouldn't keep getting reprinted), but to me Ra is considerably better.
Verdict - OK, I can't see that I'd ever refuse a game if it was all that was on offer, but there are a lot that I'd play in preference.
Anyway that was quite enough auction action for one session. I think I need to steer clear of auctions for a bit, unless they're in a Power Grid context (or may be Ra).
Until next week
Labels:
Wednesday Sessions
Tuesday, 10 July 2007
Session Summary - 4 July 2007
Sorry for the delay in this report, I've been thinking long and hard about the coments that follow.
There were 4 of us tonight and we played one game.
This was my first play at this. What we have is a game where you represent impresarios in Imperial Rome competing to put on the best attended shows in your arena at the end of 100 days of celebration for the opening of the Colosseum, so that would put us at 80AD under the emperor Titus. On each turn players have the opportunity to invest in upgrading their arena in some way or to buy the rights to produce a particular show. Following this there is a series of auctions for the various component assets required to put on the show (such as gladiators, horses and quite a few others) and some special tiles . Then there is a round where players may trade assets and money between themselves. Following this each player rolls a die or dice to move important persons (in the hope of getting them, either into their arena where they add to the attendance of the upcoming show or into the local resting place to gain a medal which can be exchanged for money, an increase in the value of the upcoming show or the opportunity to make an extra investment in a following turn) before putting on their show which will cause the loss of one of the assets used. Money is earned according to the number of spectators at the show and the players score at the end will be that for the best attended of the five shows that he will produce during the game.
In this game I went last on the first turn and had the chance to see what the others did as their investment, Matt & Steve went for an Emperor's loge giving an extra die to roll, while Mike went for a season ticket giving +5 spectators at all future shows, I went with Mike, but this was a mistake in retrospect as having now played the game, it seems like a complete no-brainer to go with the loge as having 2 dice as early as possible seems vital, also the loge is 5 coins less giving you more money to spend in the coming first round of auctions.
As the game progressed Matt was in the lead and earned the podium (given to the leader each turn and granting +3 spectators at future shows) for the first 4 rounds, the rest of us were reasonably close together early on, but Steve was building up a large number of medals. Although I kept up for the first four turns, I dropped back at the end as I had not upgraded the size of my arena to the largest size, so couldn't produce one of the larger shows. It was at this point that Steve leapt ahead by virtue of his stock of medals, Matt who was somewhat short in that regard fell behind and was almost caught by Mike.
Now some comments about the game, it is beautifully produced as one would expect from Days of Wonder, has an interesting theme and is set in a period of interest to me, that said most games are pretty well produced these days and I think the period was largely irrelevant, you could for example have just as well used another (e.g. Elizabethan England, you too can be Shakespeare). I want to like the game and will try again as I think, in this case, that it will take one game just to know really what you're doing. I do, however see a few issues with it, these are:
1. Randomness: there are several random elements which can have an effect. Most prominent is the die rolling, it cannot be stressed enough how important it is to have a stock of medals and it is here that they will be mainly be gained, if you are lucky with the dice you gain, if you are not you lose. As you will only roll a maximum of 10 dice during the game there is not much time for good & bad rolls to even themselves out. Another point is the random availability of assets, there may be nothing very useful available, when it is your turn to initiate an auction, you can of course choose to pass in the hope that something good will come up later, but then you are at the mercy of another player to put the assets up, which he is unlikely to do if they are clearly advantageous to someone else. This happened to me on turn 4, when Matt declined to auction (correctly for him) a combination which would have given me 2 of the star performers. I got the tiles the following turn. Finally there is the factor of the random starting distribution of assets and shows, it seems to me that it is a big advantage if a player gets a favourable combination, for instance a lot of commonality between the shows received or (as Matt got this time) an exact match between assets received and one of the shows, as it leaves you freer to go for long term planning without having to worry so much about putting on your early shows.
2. Analysis Paralysis: as the newbie watching the three who had played before, it was clear that long term planning was going on with regard to what assets and shows to get, it is obviously an advantage to be able to reuse your assets in a series of shows. This showed itself sometimes, with players spending a long time when deciding what assets to put up for auction.
3. There seems to be a problem with players wanting the same assets to put on a show, if a player gets hold of them first, they are not going to want to trade and this situation is unlikely to change, if they are (as seems logical) trying to reuse those assets in successive shows.
4. It may be because I was new and did not know what I was doing, but the game seems too long. Certainly I was looking forward to the end some time before it actually occurred.
As I usually try to do after being taught a game for the first time, I have been and had a look at the rules and I think we may have been doing a few things wrong (please correct me if I'm wrong about this as I may have missed it).
Firstly, although I never did it, I thought people were exchanging a single medal to make an extra investment, the rules say it should be two. As I say I never did this and I may be wrong and other players were doing it correctly.
Second, I distinctly remember medals being requested in trade, I do not recall if any such trades were actually made, but the rules are clear that only money and assets may be traded.
Third in the auctions, the rules are clear that a player may not win more than one auction in a turn, we weren't doing this. I notice that there is an "Extreme Auction" variant in the rules, which would make this right, were we playing this?
So that's my first impression, I will play again with the benefit of more knowledge of what I'm doing, but after one game I do not get the immediate good feeling I got from Pillars of the Earth or, to a lesser extent Notre Dame.
See you tomorrow.
There were 4 of us tonight and we played one game.
| Colosseum 120 mins | ||
| Player | Posn. | Points |
| Steve H | 1 | 107 |
| Matt | 2 | 93 |
| Mike | 3 | 88 |
| Dave D | 4 | 65 |
This was my first play at this. What we have is a game where you represent impresarios in Imperial Rome competing to put on the best attended shows in your arena at the end of 100 days of celebration for the opening of the Colosseum, so that would put us at 80AD under the emperor Titus. On each turn players have the opportunity to invest in upgrading their arena in some way or to buy the rights to produce a particular show. Following this there is a series of auctions for the various component assets required to put on the show (such as gladiators, horses and quite a few others) and some special tiles . Then there is a round where players may trade assets and money between themselves. Following this each player rolls a die or dice to move important persons (in the hope of getting them, either into their arena where they add to the attendance of the upcoming show or into the local resting place to gain a medal which can be exchanged for money, an increase in the value of the upcoming show or the opportunity to make an extra investment in a following turn) before putting on their show which will cause the loss of one of the assets used. Money is earned according to the number of spectators at the show and the players score at the end will be that for the best attended of the five shows that he will produce during the game.
In this game I went last on the first turn and had the chance to see what the others did as their investment, Matt & Steve went for an Emperor's loge giving an extra die to roll, while Mike went for a season ticket giving +5 spectators at all future shows, I went with Mike, but this was a mistake in retrospect as having now played the game, it seems like a complete no-brainer to go with the loge as having 2 dice as early as possible seems vital, also the loge is 5 coins less giving you more money to spend in the coming first round of auctions.
As the game progressed Matt was in the lead and earned the podium (given to the leader each turn and granting +3 spectators at future shows) for the first 4 rounds, the rest of us were reasonably close together early on, but Steve was building up a large number of medals. Although I kept up for the first four turns, I dropped back at the end as I had not upgraded the size of my arena to the largest size, so couldn't produce one of the larger shows. It was at this point that Steve leapt ahead by virtue of his stock of medals, Matt who was somewhat short in that regard fell behind and was almost caught by Mike.
Now some comments about the game, it is beautifully produced as one would expect from Days of Wonder, has an interesting theme and is set in a period of interest to me, that said most games are pretty well produced these days and I think the period was largely irrelevant, you could for example have just as well used another (e.g. Elizabethan England, you too can be Shakespeare). I want to like the game and will try again as I think, in this case, that it will take one game just to know really what you're doing. I do, however see a few issues with it, these are:
1. Randomness: there are several random elements which can have an effect. Most prominent is the die rolling, it cannot be stressed enough how important it is to have a stock of medals and it is here that they will be mainly be gained, if you are lucky with the dice you gain, if you are not you lose. As you will only roll a maximum of 10 dice during the game there is not much time for good & bad rolls to even themselves out. Another point is the random availability of assets, there may be nothing very useful available, when it is your turn to initiate an auction, you can of course choose to pass in the hope that something good will come up later, but then you are at the mercy of another player to put the assets up, which he is unlikely to do if they are clearly advantageous to someone else. This happened to me on turn 4, when Matt declined to auction (correctly for him) a combination which would have given me 2 of the star performers. I got the tiles the following turn. Finally there is the factor of the random starting distribution of assets and shows, it seems to me that it is a big advantage if a player gets a favourable combination, for instance a lot of commonality between the shows received or (as Matt got this time) an exact match between assets received and one of the shows, as it leaves you freer to go for long term planning without having to worry so much about putting on your early shows.
2. Analysis Paralysis: as the newbie watching the three who had played before, it was clear that long term planning was going on with regard to what assets and shows to get, it is obviously an advantage to be able to reuse your assets in a series of shows. This showed itself sometimes, with players spending a long time when deciding what assets to put up for auction.
3. There seems to be a problem with players wanting the same assets to put on a show, if a player gets hold of them first, they are not going to want to trade and this situation is unlikely to change, if they are (as seems logical) trying to reuse those assets in successive shows.
4. It may be because I was new and did not know what I was doing, but the game seems too long. Certainly I was looking forward to the end some time before it actually occurred.
As I usually try to do after being taught a game for the first time, I have been and had a look at the rules and I think we may have been doing a few things wrong (please correct me if I'm wrong about this as I may have missed it).
Firstly, although I never did it, I thought people were exchanging a single medal to make an extra investment, the rules say it should be two. As I say I never did this and I may be wrong and other players were doing it correctly.
Second, I distinctly remember medals being requested in trade, I do not recall if any such trades were actually made, but the rules are clear that only money and assets may be traded.
Third in the auctions, the rules are clear that a player may not win more than one auction in a turn, we weren't doing this. I notice that there is an "Extreme Auction" variant in the rules, which would make this right, were we playing this?
So that's my first impression, I will play again with the benefit of more knowledge of what I'm doing, but after one game I do not get the immediate good feeling I got from Pillars of the Earth or, to a lesser extent Notre Dame.
See you tomorrow.
Labels:
Wednesday Sessions
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)